Whither Invasive Competion: How Right is Benton Then?

Plant invasions and extinction debts

Authors:

1. Benjamin Gilbert (a,b)
2. Jonathan M. Levine (b,c)

Affiliations:

a. Department of Ecology and Evolutionary Biology, University of Toronto, Toronto, ON, Canada M5S 3B2;

b. Department of Ecology, Evolution, and Marine Biology, University of California, Santa Barbara, CA 93106

c. Institute for Integrative Biology, Eidgenössiche Technische Hochschule Zurich, 8092 Zurich, Switzerland

Abstract:

Whether introduced species invasions pose a major threat to biodiversity is hotly debated. Much of this debate is fueled by recent findings that competition from introduced organisms has driven remarkably few plant species to extinction. Instead, native plant species in invaded ecosystems are often found in refugia: patchy, marginal habitats unsuitable to their nonnative competitors. However, whether the colonization and extinction dynamics of these refugia allow long-term native persistence is uncertain. Of particular concern is the possibility that invasive plants may induce an extinction debt in the native flora, where persistence over the short term masks deterministic extinction trajectories. We examined how invader impacts on landscape structure influence native plant persistence by combining recently developed quantitative techniques for evaluating metapopulation persistence with field measurements of an invaded plant community. We found that European grass invasion of an edaphically heterogeneous California landscape has greatly decreased the likelihood of the persistence of native metapopulations. It does so via two main pathways: (i) decreasing the size of native refugia, which reduces seed production and increases local extinction, and (ii) eroding the dispersal permeability of the matrix between refugia, which reduces their connectivity. Even when native plant extinction is the deterministic outcome of invasion, the time to extinction can be on the order of hundreds of years. We conclude that the relatively short time since invasion in many parts of the world is insufficient to observe the full impact of plant invasions on native biodiversity.

Or is he?