Permian Triassic Impact Araguainha Impact Did Not Cause the Mass Extinction, But Left Its Mark

Shaking a methane fizz: Seismicity from the Araguainha impact event and the Permian–Triassic global carbon isotope record

Authors:

1. E. Tohver (a)

2. P.A. Cawood (a, b)

3. C. Riccomini (c)

4. C. Lana (d)

5. R.I.F. Trindade (c)

Affiliations:

a. School of Earth & Environment, University of Western Australia, Australia

b. St. Andrews University, Scotland, United Kingdom

c. Universidade de São Paulo, Brazil

d. Universidade Federal de Ouro Preto, Brazil

Abstract:

The Late Permian and Early Triassic periods are marked by large fluctuations in the carbon isotope record, but the source(s) of the disturbance to the global carbon cycle and the link to the end–Permian mass extinction are widely debated. This contribution explores the possible isotopic effects of an impact event into the hydrocarbon-rich rocks of the Paraná-Karoo basin. Recent U–Pb and 40Ar/39Ar dating of the 40 km Araguainha impact structure of central Brazil reveals an age of 254.7±2.5 Ma (2σ error) for this event. The calculated energy (105–106 MT of TNT equivalent) released by this impact is less than threshold values of 107–108 MT TNT equivalent for global mass extinctions. Thus, the Araguainha crater is unlikely to have been the cause of the end–Permian biotic crisis. However, the combined seismic effects from the impact itself and the post-impact collapse of the 20–25 km diameter transient crater to its present 40 km diameter would result in large magnitude earthquakes (Mw 9.3–10.5) and tsunamis in the shallow marine Paraná-Karoo Basin. Slope failure and sediment liquefaction are predicted to have occurred within a 700–3000 km radius of the crater, causing large-scale release of methane from organic-rich sediments of this basin, including the oil shale horizons of the Iratí Formation. New geological evidence for seismicity in the Paraná Basin at the time of impact is presented, together with a compilation of existing carbon isotope data from the Paranáa Basin, which demonstrate a widespread pattern of disturbance consistent with the release of methane. These two datasets suggest that both seismicity and methane release took place within ca.1000 km of the impact site, with mass balance calculations suggesting ca. 1600 gigatons of methane were released into the atmosphere at this time. Methane release at this scale would have significant climate effects and would contribute to a sharp (< 1 ka) negative shift in δ13C values at the time of the impact, which should be distinguishable from the more gradual shift over 0.5 – 1 Ma caused by contemporaneous intrusion of the Siberian traps.